Blog
Why Most Self-Confidence Training is Actually Making You Worse
Related Articles:
Right, let's get one thing straight from the start. If you've been to one of those rah-rah self-confidence workshops where someone in a shiny suit tells you to "fake it till you make it" whilst charging you $300 for the privilege, you've been had. Properly had.
I've been running workplace training programmes across Australia for nearly two decades now, and I can tell you with absolute certainty that 80% of what passes for confidence training is complete rubbish. Worse than rubbish, actually. It's actively harmful.
Here's what really gets my goat: these so-called experts keep peddling the same tired mantras without understanding the fundamental psychology of confidence. They're treating symptoms, not causes. Like putting a Band-Aid on a broken leg.
The Problem With Positive Affirmations
Let me share something that'll probably annoy half of you reading this. Those daily affirmations everyone bangs on about? "I am confident, I am powerful, I am unstoppable"? They're making most people feel worse about themselves.
Think about it logically for a second. If you genuinely believed you were confident, would you need to stand in front of a mirror every morning trying to convince yourself? It's like trying to tickle yourself—your brain knows you're lying.
I learned this the hard way back in 2009 when I was running confidence workshops in Brisbane. Had this brilliant accountant, Sarah, who'd been doing positive affirmations religiously for six months. Came to my session more anxious than when she started. Why? Because every time she said "I am confident," her brain immediately replied with evidence to the contrary.
The human mind isn't stupid. It knows when you're talking nonsense.
What Actually Works (And Why Most People Get It Wrong)
Real confidence isn't about believing you're amazing at everything. That's narcissism, not confidence. Real confidence is about knowing you can handle whatever comes your way, even if you mess up spectacularly.
I've worked with executives from companies like Westpac and Telstra, and you know what the truly confident ones have in common? They're comfortable with being uncomfortable. They've failed enough times to know it's not the end of the world.
Here's where most training goes wrong: it focuses on feeling confident rather than building actual competence. But confidence without competence is just arrogance with better marketing.
The best confidence training I've ever delivered was to a team of engineers in Perth. Instead of making them repeat mantras, we put them in progressively challenging situations where they could succeed through preparation and skill. Started small—presenting to their immediate team—then gradually increased the stakes.
By the end of three months, these introverted engineers were confidently presenting to senior management. Not because they felt amazing about themselves, but because they'd proven to themselves they could do it.
The Melbourne Mistake
Between you and me, there's something happening in Melbourne's corporate training scene that's driving me mental. Everyone's obsessed with "confidence coaches" who've never actually run a business or managed people. They've got Instagram accounts full of motivational quotes but couldn't handle a difficult stakeholder meeting if their life depended on it.
I had a client last year—won't name names, but it's a major retailer—who'd spent $15,000 on confidence coaching for their management team. The "coach" had them doing trust falls and writing gratitude journals. Six months later, they called me because their team was still avoiding difficult conversations like the plague.
Know what we did instead? Role-played every difficult scenario they might face. Gave them scripts, strategies, and backup plans. Confidence through competence, not empty cheerleading.
The Science Bit (Don't Worry, I'll Keep It Simple)
There's actually solid research behind why traditional confidence training fails. Psychologist Albert Bandura identified four sources of self-efficacy (that's psychology speak for "belief in your ability to succeed"):
- Mastery experiences - Actually succeeding at stuff
- Vicarious experiences - Watching others succeed
- Verbal persuasion - Encouragement from others
- Physiological arousal - Managing your physical responses
Most confidence training focuses entirely on number four—trying to make you feel better—whilst completely ignoring the first three. It's like trying to build a house starting with the roof.
The companies I work with that see real results focus heavily on mastery experiences. They break down complex tasks into manageable chunks, celebrate small wins, and gradually increase challenges.
Why Australian Businesses Are Finally Getting This Right
Here's something that might surprise you: Australian businesses are actually leading the world in evidence-based confidence training. We've always been pretty good at cutting through BS, and confidence training was overdue for the Australian treatment.
I've noticed a real shift in the last three years. Instead of hiring motivational speakers who've never faced a real workplace challenge, companies are investing in practical skills training. They're focusing on building actual capabilities rather than just making people feel good temporarily.
Take customer service training, for example. Instead of telling staff to "believe in yourself," we teach them exactly how to handle difficult conversations and deal with hostile customers. When they've got the skills and strategies, confidence follows naturally.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Confidence
Right, here's something that might make you squirm a bit. True confidence often means accepting that you're not confident about everything. And that's perfectly fine.
I'm supremely confident when it comes to designing training programmes or handling workplace conflicts. Put me in front of 200 people talking about change management, and I'm in my element. But ask me to fix a car engine or perform surgery? I'd be useless and anxious, and rightly so.
The problem with generic confidence training is it tries to make you feel confident about everything. That's not confidence; that's delusion.
Smart professionals know their limitations and work within them or actively address them through skill development. That's real confidence.
What Works: The Three-Pillar Approach
After seventeen years of trial and error (and let me tell you, there were some spectacular errors), I've developed what I call the Three-Pillar Approach to confidence building:
Pillar One: Competence Building Stop trying to feel confident and start getting good at stuff. Want confidence in presentations? Practice presentations. Want confidence in negotiations? Learn negotiation techniques. Sounds obvious, but you'd be amazed how many people skip this step.
Pillar Two: Preparation Protocols Confidence comes from knowing you're ready. I teach my clients to prepare for the worst-case scenario, not just the best case. When you've got a plan for when things go wrong, you can relax when things go right.
Pillar Three: Recovery Strategies This is the big one that everyone misses. True confidence isn't about never failing; it's about knowing you can bounce back from failure. We practice recovery scenarios until they become automatic.
I remember working with a sales team in Adelaide who were terrified of objections. Instead of pretending objections wouldn't happen, we role-played every possible objection and developed responses for each one. Six months later, they were actually looking forward to objections because they'd become so good at handling them.
The Adelaide Revelation
Speaking of Adelaide, I had what I call my "confidence epiphany" there in 2016. Was running a workshop for a manufacturing company, and this supervisor, Mike, absolutely refused to participate. Sat at the back with his arms crossed, rolling his eyes at everything.
During the lunch break, I cornered him. Turns out he'd been sent to four confidence courses in two years by HR. All of them had been the touchy-feely, "believe in yourself" variety. He was convinced it was all rubbish.
So I made him a deal. Skip the feel-good stuff and just focus on practical skills. We identified the three situations where he felt least confident: giving feedback to underperformers, presenting monthly reports, and dealing with angry customers.
We spent the afternoon working through specific techniques for each scenario. By the end of the day, Mike was volunteering to demonstrate the techniques to others. Not because he suddenly felt amazing about himself, but because he had actual tools he could use.
Three months later, his manager called to say Mike had become their most effective supervisor. He wasn't more confident; he was more competent. The confidence was just a byproduct.
The Remote Work Confidence Crisis
Here's something nobody talks about: remote work has created a whole new set of confidence challenges. When you're sitting in your home office in your trackies, it's harder to feel like the professional powerhouse you are at the office.
I've been working with teams across Australia to address this, and the solution isn't about creating a "confidence corner" in your home office (though some people swear by it). It's about developing new competencies for the remote work environment.
This includes mastering video call presence, learning to communicate effectively in writing, and developing the discipline to maintain professional standards without external accountability. These are skills, not feelings.
Companies like Canva have done brilliant work in this area, creating structured programmes that build remote work competencies rather than just trying to make people feel better about working from home.
Why Most Confidence Training Fails: The Real Reason
Alright, here's the bit that might ruffle some feathers in the training industry. Most confidence training fails because it's designed by people who've never actually lacked confidence.
You know the type—naturally charismatic extroverts who've been confident since they learned to walk. They genuinely don't understand what it's like to feel anxious about speaking up in meetings or presenting to senior leadership.
It's like getting fitness advice from someone who's naturally athletic and has never struggled with weight. They can tell you what works for them, but they can't relate to your starting point.
The best confidence trainers I know are people who've overcome their own confidence challenges through practical methods. They understand the journey because they've been on it themselves.
The Future of Confidence Training
Looking ahead, I predict we'll see a complete shift away from feel-good confidence training towards competency-based approaches. The organisations that thrive will be those that focus on building actual skills rather than just making people feel temporarily better about themselves.
We're already seeing this in progressive companies across Australia. They're investing in specific skill development rather than generic confidence boosting. Want confident leaders? Teach leadership skills. Want confident salespeople? Teach sales techniques.
It's not rocket science, but it does require a fundamental shift in thinking. From "fake it till you make it" to "learn it till you earn it."
The future belongs to practical, evidence-based training that builds real capabilities. Everything else is just expensive therapy disguised as professional development.
About the Author: After seventeen years of running workplace training programmes across Australia, I've learned that the best confidence training doesn't feel like confidence training at all. It feels like skill building. Because that's exactly what it is.